The one star is for the milk toy and the horrible customer service I received. Happiness definitely not guaranteed. Within minutes of my dog playing with the milk carton, the red paint on it started to bleed (and no, my dog was not bleeding as was insinuated by customer service - you can clearly see the red is lighter where it bled onto the white). I took it away from her immediately and told customer service about it. Their response was disappointing and a little appalling. The only other time I dealt with customer service about another toy, they were so helpful and efficient. I told my friends I would definitely be buying more toys from the Bark shop after that. I will now be reconsidering that. Only redeeming thing is the cookie has held up well and my dog enjoys it.

Both of my dogs LOVED this set. The milk is probably their favorite toy ever. I bought a second when the first had finally been destroyed. They love it just as much.

I wish the milk had been plush.