This toy was my packs absolute favorite and so creative and fun!

My dog Mackey LOVES this toy. He is blind and gets disinterested in playing with the same toys over and over. Not the case with Cookie Monster. He plays with this daily. We just ordered a new one since he ripped off the cover. Will likely order a few more for backup!

The title says it all. This toy is great for your rough and tumbled dog who thrives on destruction. In its initial stage you start off with something fluffy, floppy, and heavy. The perfect companion for a dog who likes to shake the tar out of things; and the added weight might even help tire your dog out too.

The next stage comes when your dog has successfully eviscerated this beloved childhood character. In a delightfully twisted turn of events, they get a cookie. A nice thick rubber cookie that your dog may or may not be able to successfully squeak (I'll take durability over sound anyday).

The last stage comes when your dog remembers there's still a little bit of destroying left to do. Once your dog has successfully ripped off cooking monster face; everyone is greeted with a still smiling cookie monster. The cookie monster head is still durable but a little bit easier for your dog to squeak.

In the end you should be left with 2, possibly even 3 toys depending on how long you let them play with the skin.

I hope my colorful review has conveyed just how much I love this toy. I've had the rubber core toys in the past but they haven't really interested my dogs that much. Cookie monster I guess just seems to have more of a prey feel to it.

I sincerely hope BarkBox intends to make more 2 piece rubber core toys in the future.

My dog loves the ones with a plush outer layer he can tear through. He’s definitely a super chewer, so normal plush toys aren’t worth my while (they last .2 seconds), but these have more toys inside! He especially likes the ones inside the Cookie Monster (one of them is scented and he loves that). I’m very fond of BarkShop toys and this one takes the cake in my opinion! Def recommend!

I’m glad I got this in my Bark Box because from the general description I wouldn’t have probably picked it to purchase and it’s one of the coolest toys we’ve gotten from Bark so far. I have a “Super Chewer” dog that happens to also love fluffy toys. When we buy him non fluffy toys they just sit there, so this one is the best of both worlds! It’s pretty tough, even the fluffy outer layer…it took him almost 3 weeks of play to rip through. But that’s the best part of this toy…because inside you get TWO more toys to play with! He likes the Cookie head one the best and loves that it squeaks. I’ve ran both the rubber toys through the dish washer after some outdoor play and they are still going strong. Buy this one now, you won’t regret it!