I bought mine three years ago. Some of the velcro finally wore out, but I just put in a metal snap to hold it closed and I’m expecting to get several more years of use before I need to replace it. I tried several other brands that generally wore out in a year or so of use, so this has been by far the best one I’ve owned.

I actually had another one of these from BarkShop that was accidentally broken but otherwise in great shape after about 1 year of use. I LOVE these because they're perfectly functional and easy to use, but also because the material is durable and soft, so that if it does bounce back or hit myself or my dog accidentally while walking, leashing up, etc. it's not hard plastic. I spot clean by hand with dish soap, but I expect the black will conceal dirtiness well. If you walk any dog, you should have one of these!

Definitely better quality than the amazon one its replacing

The bag holder is made well just like all the barkbox products I have bought so far. My old one show dirt so I’m sure the black one won’t.

My other poo bag was falling apart. The quality I see and feel I know this bag will last me a long while.