My dogs LOVE this toy.. They both love crinkle toys, and one likes to shake toys and hit herself in the face. The igloo is perfect for that, no signs of shredding so far (5months) That tennis ball was a game changer for the other one, once she learned it squeaked lol. Now she will only bring me that ball to play fetch with... She is in the process of ripping off its flippers but surprisingly its not coming apart like I thought. Very well made, good product.