I have had 6!months of Bark Box and my puppy has loved all of the toys! However, he has turned his nose up at EVERY treat in the boxes. Do not feel badly because he has done the same with ALL treats. I was packing all of the treats up to take to the animal shelter when I saw that the clucks jerky sticks had not been opened. I opened and gave a portion to my puppy and he ate it and wanted more! I was amazed and excited because I was able to cut them into tiny bits and use them for training. I finally have something that he cares about enough to follow my training commands. Just wish it was easier to find.