My dog likes this toy. My bulldog is a heavy chewer and this has held up fairly well. There is some chew marks around the top but that's it. I will say the one I received did not squeak, so I took off one star for that, besides it not squeaking I'm happy with the toy.
Sorry to hear Mikkel's Rocking Stocking had no squeaks! Feel free to reach out at Barksocial@barkshop.com so we can assist with a replacement =)